Product Review: EasyGenerator Rapid Content Authoring Tool

EasyGenerator

EasyGenerator is a SaaS based content authoring tool that is like a piece of fine sculpture, with some cracks, but beauty that is hidden within.

Good, Average & Poor

Good

• Extremely feature rich – can compete with Captivate and other authoring tools
• Can use images and video with text and move the text separately from the object, something many RCATs can’t do because they use grouping which cannot be un-grouped
• Workspace mode is seen in real time, so u do not have to preview it every time to see an update. You see it in a large window on your screen
• Editing and enhancing is simple to do
• Can be used by someone brand new to RCATs, as well as someone who is very advanced – enough capabilities for all
• Properties positioning or components robust
• Vendor can create a component so you can push directly into your LMS, without having to upload it directly (extra cost)
• Preview window can be seen in Chrome, IE, Firefox and Safari browsers, and when choosing preview will do so – based on your set criteria of what browser to do so (within the product)
• Language option enables you to see output responses, etc. in your native language, so you are not stuck creating responses or comments, or other properties in English if your native language is Russian
• Publish Options: SCORM 2004, SCORM 1.2, HTML or stand alone
• Built in question pool, assessment tool and survey tool
• Unbelievable amount of fonts to select from: The most I have ever seen in a content authoring tool
• Can create and edit in HTML, plus offers CSS features

Average

• Workflow hierarchy when you build your courses, lessons, etc.
• Randomize questions and responses
• Offers ability to create a TOC (Table of Contents)

Poor

• Can create your courses only in Internet Explorer, but as mentioned you can preview and have your courses seen in the other browsers
• If you do not have or use IE, you can download a desktop version to build, sort of defeats the purpose of SaaS
• All the language options worked as stated, but French showed English (I surmise a bug)
• Slow when building your course or content (more on that later)
• Video in the course has to be .flv, it cannot be .avi, .wmv, .mp4
• Some of the defaults make no sense when selecting the type of element within the course

Huh?

• The tool can track your courses – if a standalone -

Main Screen

When you enter EasyGenerator the first thing you will notice is the main screen – which is dubbed the “Workspace” screen

• Course build hierarchy on left side
• Course window – on right side

  Within the left side of screen, where your hierarchy to build your course exists, you can switch to “Files”.

The “Files” area contains all the images, video, audio, etc., that exists within your course, plus offers some additional features.  I liked the fact you could see your files in a separate section within the tool, because it you need to upload or remove a file you can, quickly.

The hiearchry starts with a project folder, which you name and then lists each section, underneath it. You select the sections, which include

• Sub-menus
• Course
• Glossary
• Chapters
• Lessons
• Questions/Exam
• Survey

You can add as many elements as you want and then move them up or down the hierarchy.  What I found wonderful is the listing of “chapters”, this tells me that the folks at EasyGenerator get it when it comes to web based training course development, which sadly isn’t universal in our space (but should be).

You can also set your properties in the left side within the work tree.

  I will say this about EasyGenerator, the properties is so extensive in this program, that you should not have any issue on what the outcome or desired effect should be.  On the flip side for some people it can be overwhelming, but the properties is completely optional.

Build properties

• General – course title, master page, launch course (choose either embedded in LMS or pop up window)
• Language (English, Russian (appearing text wise as Russian and not the word “Russian), Nederlands, Deutsch, Francais

• Publishing – Manifest ID, course type (lesson, survey, test, final exam, custom), mastery score, mastery score reached status (passed or completed), show feedback, make score equal to progress, allow course to be repeated when passed/failed/completed, show score when completed

One issue I had with the publishing option came with the set defaults (which you can click on or off) and course type.  For “Lesson” the defaults on where all the options except for maximum number of attempts. 

So if you do not want “make score equal to progress” and why would you for a lesson or page, the type immediately changes to “custom”.

The same thing occurred – but different default options for test, survey, etc., and again, if you decide to change one of the defaults, your type switches to custom. 

The logic just didn’t make sense. Why even have the course types if the moment you change one default it goes to custom? Wouldn’t you rather identify “custom” as just that – some custom type not listed in your original options?

The other build properties are

• Objectives
• Meta data – keywords, description
• Advanced

The top of screen features the dashboard, which is quite robust, and uses icons to display components available to you. Equally nice is you merely have to place your mouse cursor over the object to find out what it is.  Again, great job.

Dashboard

The dashboard as I like to call it, is quite robust. Depending on what you are doing during your build, certain objects within the board will be grayed out, thus unavailable to you. As aforementioned the amount of fonts you can use is unbelievable, plus the ability to choose the various types of text colors is in alignment with many web site tools, and rarely seen in course authoring tools.

Let’s take a look at the bottom object bar

From L-R

• Folder
• Course
• Sub Menu
• Chapter
• Question Pool
• Glossary
• Package
• Course Link – really a hyperlink
• File Link
• Text – creates a text box in the main screen (right side), which you can type in, edit, etc.
• Image – .jpg, .tiff, .bmp, .png
• Image with text – shows up side by side in the main screen, but you can move it around – “ungrouped” – WONDERFUL
• Video – .flv only
• Video with text – same premise as Image with text 
• Flash
• Flash with text
• Question types – M/C, M/C with Image, Text, Fill in the blanks, Statement, Hotspot, Drag n Drop, Matching, Ranking, Ranking with image, Likert (WOW), Open, Flash

As you can see there are more then enough types of questions to choose from, although the “T/F” doesn’t really exist. You can do it, but you have to use “Statement” and it is not as simple of typing in “True” or “False” as the correct/incorrect choices. EasyGenerator requires you to enter statements too and won’t let you move on, until you do so. 

This can be easily be avoided, but just creating a T/F question option. Especially when they offer “Text” as a question option.

Main Screen

Within the main screen (the mid to right side) creating a lesson, question is easy to do. First, select the object you want to appear in the TOC – such as a lesson (better term use would be “page”) then after entering the title and clicking save, the build can commence in front of you. 

In my test, after creating the opening text – with a simple click of the object “Text” on my dashboard, I was able to type in the text box which appears in the main screen and start working.

On the top of the text box, you see two icons. One is properties, the other is delete.

When I decided to add video with text, again I selected the object and within my main screen I saw

After entering the video and text, you can move them around anywhere on the screen, and thus they would appear that way in your course. Again, a nice feature, considering many RCATs have them auto grouped.

You can delete the title and caption if you so choose, and even add more text on the page – text box, image or flash. 

Every change, add, new part appears in real time, but here lies an issue I have with Easy Generator.

Time

In the build mode, I found the time it took to add any element on the left side, which upon doing so, updates the work tree for you to see AND any time I entered in new content or made edits or whatever in the main screen, again the program updates it immediately – it took a long time.

At first I thought it was due to my speed, so I went as tested my bandwidth. I was running at 16Mbps, which is very fast for at a household. When initally viewing the demo with EasyGenerator their speed was extremely quick, so the issue may arise on where exactly are you hitting the SaaS site from, in terms of at the workplace or off-site.

While a large number of businesses, etc. use T1 or higher, for a household that isn’t the case. Most people hit with a DSL at a lower speed or via a cable modem at 2Mbps.  When you factor in a wireless network at home, the speed tends to drop a little there, then depending on where you live – urban area versus in the country, speed can drop too.

For myself, the speed is more than robust, but with EasyGenerator it was painful. Rather than an immediate update view, some went as much as six to eight seconds.

While you may think that isn’t a big deal, think about it, every time you make a tiny add or edit. Even when entering in text for the title of a lesson or course. 

At one point, for an edit within the main screen, it went 10 seconds, at which point, I had to literally walk away from my laptop because irritation had set in.

The result of course, is you do not want to do anything, which is sad considering the robustness of ease of use of the product. 

Other Features

• Insert columns, tables
• Preview course in browser
• Search function, move up or down within the work tree menu
• Navigation for questions – can jump to the next question or opt for new rules – enabling the end user to answer question 4, then jump to question 9 as a result of their response
• File, Edit, View, Tools and Help
• Under the tools – is the publish option, which seems better to be listed as a header – thus File, Edit, View, Publish, Help then under Tools

Bottom Line

EasyGenerator can compete with any rapid content authoring tool on the market. Its richness in features for beginners to advanced sets it apart from some other key names in the market, who either focus too much on the beginner with little for the advanced developer or designer.

Its strength of the main screen real time changes is equally its weakness because of the lag time for changes to appear. While the time may seem nonsequential, for a developer it can become nerve racking.

Sure, many people build within the workplace, but in today’s market, more and more employees are working from home – especially in course development or instructional design.

Hurting the product an additional step is the inability to use the SaaS version of the product – which it identifies itself as such, unless you use Internet Explorer. The funny thing here is that overall market share for Internet Explorer is below 50%, so having that browser be the only one you can use when in the tool, makes little sense.

The use of the ability to track courses and scores in a rapid content authoring tool, hurts them as well. People who buy RCATs, buy them to build courses, not track them. So while an argument can be made for those who upload courses as a standalone sitting on their web site, with no tracking initially whatsoever, the reality is far from it. Even with a learning portal, many people have some type of database on the back end for tracking purposes.

Worse, it does a disservice to a product that sees itself as a content authoring tool, not a hybrid learning management system.

I like the product and its feature rich set and editing is not to be underestimated – not for end users and certainly not for other vendors in the space.

Unless they can solve the lag time and make some updates to their product, this potential masterpiece will end up hidden from view.

Which any product never wants to be.

E-Learning 24/7